I realize that I may be a little late to the game on this one since the controversy began in October, but WTF is this??
For those of you who can't (or don't want to) watch the video, that's a commercial for Dr Pepper TEN. It shows a couple of very "manly" men with guns, tearing through the jungle & drinking the product in a Jeep during what looks like a terrible low-budget action film. The tag line at the end is the kicker:
"Dr Pepper TEN: IT'S NOT FOR WOMEN."
So, someone thought this was a good idea. In fact, I'd dare to venture that several people thought it was a good idea, considering how many people this slogan probably had to go through to make it onto billboards and television. I have a hard time believing that nobody stood up and asserted what a terrible idea it was, because it's glaringly obvious to me and the rest of the internet.
Clearly, a lot of people were high when they created this campaign. Or there were no women involved in the process whatsoever. Aside from the ad being blatantly sexist (Women like romantic comedies! Men like action movies!), I see a few problems with the idea behind it. Namely:
1. Men who would fall for an ad like this generally aren't the same ones who would care about how many calories they're ingesting.
2. Men who care about counting calories often have a wife or girlfriend who does the grocery shopping. (Up to 85% of grocery shopping is done by women--you would think that these sexist dudes would have thought of that)
3. They've alienated at least 2/3 (I'm being generous) of the market: the ones without penises and the ones who would like to use their penises again with someone of the fairer sex. I see a guy drinking this stuff, I think he's a jerk. He may not be a jerk, but it's hard to get that association out of my head now that it's been made.
Anyway, I can't believe this ad made it to air.
The worst part is that I probably would have tried the stuff if it was a better marketing campaign. Dr. Pepper is pretty delicious, but Diet Dr. Pepper never did it for me and I'm not a fan of all that sugar. The old "Diet Dr. Pepper tastes more like regular Dr. Pepper" campaign seemed to work well...maybe they should have just made this one say "Dr. Pepper TEN tastes more like regular Dr. Pepper than Diet Dr. Pepper!". Simple, you know? I mean, is this stuff even tasty? I guess I'll never know, because I'm sure as hell not buying it.




I'd be tempted to take a picture of me drinking one of them, then send it to the tits at Dr. Pepper...
ReplyDeleteIt reminds me of the sexist Yorkie chocolate bar ad a good few years ago. Men's arguments are "Pretty much all the chocolate in the world is marketed toward women, why can't men have one marketed toward them?"
Yorkie: It's Not For Girls. http://youtu.be/LH2pLzdeCP0
I always thought Mars Bars or Snickers bars weren't exactly that girly. And I remember a male friend of mine pretty much bursting in to tears when he found out that Cadbury's Wispa bars were coming back.
I forgot about the Yorkie bars! I almost bought one at World Market once, just to try it out, but I put it down when I saw that it had a "no women" sign on the package. What idiots!
DeleteThe ad is definitely sexist, but my main problem with it is that its just not good marketing. It seems obvious and pandering - trying way to hard to be clever and look like a viral youtube video.
ReplyDeleteI think lots of men will just be reminded of the fact that diet sodas are stereotypically girly, and this commercial won't change their minds.
The fact is that the majority of the market for diet soda is women, and while I can understand seeing the dollar signs of successfully winning over an untapped market, they should try to do it without pissing off the women who would otherwise have wanted to buy it
LOL, I love #1. So true! I wonder how their sales are doing.
ReplyDeleteWow...that some atrocious marketing. I'll be honest here, though...I've never heard of it before. Probably because we don't watch broadcast television (thank you, Netflix) so commercials are almost non-existent. I also kind of like that I'm in the 15% of men that do grocery shopping. My wife refuses to go into a grocery store unless it's a dire emergency. She wasn't going that much before because I do all the food shopping and cooking in our house, but ever since her first pregnancy when she lost the contents of her stomach in the middle of the store, she avoids it at all costs.
ReplyDeleteI had that problem when I was pregnant too! I got over it as soon as I sent The hubby to the store and he came back with a breakfast cereal that contained 16 g of sugar, though.
DeleteI've never seen or even heard of this version of Dr. Pepper before. Must not be big in Texas. What I'm laughing at is that you're freaking out over sexist marketing?? Have you ever seen a beer commercial? Lol How about a truck commercial? Lol but you're totally right about the fact that this product should have been about a "women's" Dr. Pepper. Guys don't want a low calorie soda. Pfff
ReplyDeleteBeer commercials and truck commercials are geared towards men, but they don't come right out and say that women aren't allowed to enjoy them. Objectifying women sucks, but that's not my problem.
DeleteUgh.
ReplyDeleteI feel like most marketing definitely plays to one sex or the other, but it's pretty rare that an ad comes out and says, "Women, we don't want your business." It's so dumb I feel like it might be more dumb than sexist.
Yeah, I'm not sure why you would explicitly exclude a certain demographic from your product. I thought this was dumb the first saw it. Then I thought of how terrible this ad would be if you replaced "women" with another demographic.
ReplyDelete"Dr Pepper TEN: IT'S NOT FOR WHITE PEOPLE."
"Dr Pepper TEN: IT'S NOT FOR BABY BOOMERS."
"Dr Pepper TEN: IT'S NOT FOR MARRIED PEOPLE."
"Dr Pepper TEN: IT'S NOT FOR HOMOSEXUALS."
"Dr Pepper TEN: IT'S NOT FOR REPUBLICANS."
I could go on and on, but you get my point. I'd say this is easily one of the worst ad campaigns I've seen in a while.
PERFECT illustration of why this ad is horrible, Dave!
DeleteI'm sorry… But you guys are taking that silly commercial way way way too seriously lol
ReplyDeleteLooks like we finally found the key demographic! dingdingdingdingding! ;)
Delete